You met a friendly financial advisor at a "Free Steak Dinner" seminar.
He pitched you a product that sounded perfect: "Participate in the stock market upside, but with downside protection!"
You signed up for a Variable Annuity with $200,000 of your life savings.
A year later, the market went up 10%, but your account only grew by 5%.
Where did the rest go?
It went into the pockets of the insurance company. High-commission Variable Annuities are notorious for being one of the most expensive investment products in existence.
Disclaimer: Annuity contracts vary wildly. Withdrawals before age 59½ may trigger a 10% IRS tax penalty in addition to surrender charges. I am an educator, not your advisor.
Sold a Variable Annuity? Stop!
1. The "Fee Layer Cake" (Where Your Money Goes)
Unlike a simple ETF (costing 0.03%), Variable Annuities stack fees on top of fees. Typical costs include:
- Mortality & Expense (M&E) Risk Charge: 1.25% (Pays the salesperson's commission).
- Administrative Fees: 0.15% (Record keeping).
- Underlying Fund Fees: 1.00% (Mutual fund management fees).
- Rider Fees: 1.25% or more (For "Income Guarantees" or "Death Benefits").
Total Annual Cost: 3.50% or more.
To just break even with inflation and fees, your investments need to earn 6-7% every year. That is a heavy burden.
The Hidden Tax Trap: Unlike ETFs which enjoy low "Capital Gains" tax rates (15-20%), annuity gains are taxed as "Ordinary Income" (up to 37%+), further reducing your real return.
2. The Trap: "Surrender Charges"
You realize the fees are high, so you want to withdraw your cash.
Surprise! You can't leave easily.
Most annuities have a "Surrender Period" of 7 to 10 years. If you withdraw more than the allowed amount (usually 10% per year is free), you pay a penalty.
📉 Typical Surrender Schedule
- Year 1: 7% Penalty
- Year 2: 6% Penalty
- Year 3: 5% Penalty
- ...
- Year 8: 0% (Finally free)
On a $200,000 investment, a 7% penalty is $14,000 gone instantly.
3. The Solution: "1035 Exchange"
If you are stuck in a high-fee, low-performing annuity, you generally should NOT cash out (taxable event).
Instead, perform a Section 1035 Exchange.
- What is it? A tax-free transfer of funds from one annuity contract to another.
- The Strategy: Move your money from a "High-Commission Variable Annuity" to a "Low-Cost Investment Advisory Annuity" (like those from Vanguard, Fidelity, or Jefferson National).
- The Benefit: You stop paying 3.5% fees and start paying ~0.5%, potentially saving thousands every year.
4. When Does It Make Sense to Pay the Penalty?
Sometimes, it is mathematically better to pay the Surrender Charge and leave.
The "Break-Even" Math:
If you are paying 4% in annual fees, and the Surrender Charge is 4%.
By leaving now, you pay 4% once. If you stay, you pay 4% every year.
In this case, "ripping the band-aid off" is smarter.
(Warning: Check if your policy has a "Bonus Recapture" clause. If they gave you an upfront bonus, they might take it back if you leave early.)
5. Are All Annuities Bad?
No.
Single Premium Immediate Annuities (SPIA) (for pension-like income) or Fixed Annuities (CD alternatives) can be great tools.
The problem lies specifically with complex, high-fee Variable Annuities sold by commission-hungry agents who lock up your liquidity.
Free Your Money
Your retirement nest egg should work for you, not for an insurance company's bottom line.
Check your statement. Look for "M&E Charges" and "Surrender Value."
If the fees are eating your future, explore a 1035 Exchange today.
Action Plan:
- Find your policy contract. Look for the "Surrender Schedule" table.
- Calculate your "Free Withdrawal Amount" (usually 10% of the account value).
- Call a Fee-Only Fiduciary (not a broker) and ask: "Can you help me analyze a 1035 Exchange to a lower-cost platform?"
Helpful Resources:
Investor.gov: Variable Annuities Explained
Fidelity: Low-Cost Variable Annuities
0 Comments