Exercised Stock Options? Watch Out for the 'AMT' Tax Bomb That Could Bankrupt You

Exercised Stock Options?

It is the ultimate "Golden Handcuff" nightmare. You work for a successful company, you exercise your Incentive Stock Options (ISOs) to buy shares at a low strike price, and you feel rich because the current stock price is high. You haven't sold a single share yet.

Then, tax season arrives. You expect a normal bill. Instead, your CPA hands you a tax bill for $100,000. You don't have the cash because you didn't sell the stock. This is the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT) trap, and in 2026, it is more dangerous than ever due to the potential sunset of TCJA tax cuts.

Today, we dive into the complex world of ISOs and AMT. If you hold stock options, this might be the most important financial article you read all year.

---

The "Phantom Income" Problem

To understand the danger, you must understand how the IRS views ISOs differently than you do.

• Your View: "I bought a share for $1. It is worth $10. I haven't sold it, so I haven't made any money yet."
• IRS AMT View: "You bought a share for $1. It is worth $10. You made a 'paper profit' of $9. We want to tax that $9 now, at roughly 26% or 28%."

This "spread" (the difference between your strike price and the fair market value) counts as income for the AMT calculation. If you exercise a large number of options, your tentative minimum tax shoots up. If it exceeds your regular tax, you must pay the difference.

The Horror Story: The "Dot-Com" Crash Repeat

Why is this dangerous? Imagine you exercise stock when it is worth $100. You owe AMT based on that $100 price. But before you can sell the stock, the market crashes, and the stock drops to $10.

You still owe the IRS taxes based on the $100 price. People have literally had to sell their homes to pay taxes on stock that became worthless. Do not let this happen to you.

Strategy 1: Know Your "AMT Crossover Point" (Critical in 2026)

You don't have to stop exercising; you just need to be precise. Every taxpayer has an "AMT Exemption" amount. However, warning for 2026: If the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) provisions sunset as scheduled, AMT exemption amounts could drop significantly, capturing far more taxpayers than before.

You can exercise a specific number of ISOs each year up to the point where your tentative minimum tax equals your regular tax.

• Action: Ask your CPA to run a projection specifically for the 2026 tax year rules: "How many ISOs can I exercise this year without triggering AMT?"
• Result: You get more shares on the clock for long-term capital gains (1 year hold) without paying a penny in extra tax today.

Strategy 2: The "Disqualifying Disposition" (The Panic Button)

If you exercised early in the year and the stock price crashes by December, you have an escape hatch. It is called a Disqualifying Disposition.

By selling the stock before December 31st of the same year you exercised, you erase the AMT liability. Instead, you will just pay ordinary income tax on the actual profit (if any). This is far better than paying massive AMT on a phantom profit that no longer exists.

Strategy 3: Early Exercise & The 83(b) Election

If your company allows it, the best way to avoid AMT is to exercise your options before the stock value goes up. This is often done right when you join a startup ("Early Exercise").

If the Strike Price = Fair Market Value, the "spread" is zero. Zero spread means Zero AMT. You must file an "83(b) Election" with the IRS within a strict 30-day window. This alerts them that you bought the stock and starts the clock on long-term capital gains immediately.

Action Plan: Don't DIY Your Equity Compensation

Stock options are complex. One wrong move on a tax form can cost you 20% of your wealth.

1. Download your Grant Summary: Know your Strike Price, Vesting Schedule, and Expiration Date.
2. Calculate the Spread: (Current Price - Strike Price) x Number of Shares. This is your potential AMT income.
3. Set Aside Cash: Never exercise ISOs without having the cash on hand to pay the potential AMT bill.
4. Review in November: Always check your status before year-end to decide if you need to sell (Disqualifying Disposition) to save yourself.

(Disclaimer: This article assumes general tax rules for Incentive Stock Options (ISOs) and Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT) as of 2026. Tax laws, including the TCJA sunset, are subject to change. Individual tax situations vary greatly. This is not professional tax advice. Always consult with a CPA or tax attorney specializing in equity compensation before exercising or selling stock options.)

Protect Your Gains

Stock options can create generational wealth, but only if you navigate the AMT minefield correctly. Plan ahead, and don't let the IRS take more than their fair share.